The 5 Best Insurance Agencies in Birmingham, MI

Last updated September 26, 2026 · ranked from 1,190 Google reviews · How we rank

These five insurance agencies are all located within Birmingham, MI, with Google ratings ranging from 4.8 to 5 stars and review counts ranging from 54 to 677. David Purvis Farm Bureau Insurance Agency takes the top spot with a 5-star rating from 95 reviews. Platinum Elite ranks second with 4.9 stars from 157 reviews, followed by L.A. Insurance, which has 4.9 stars and the largest review count on the list at 677. Randahl Agency, LLC places fourth with 5 stars from 54 reviews. Terrill Mayberry - State Farm Insurance Agent rounds out the five with 4.8 stars from 207 reviews. The list keeps its focus entirely on agencies inside Birmingham, MI.

1. 1

   David Purvis Farm Bureau Insurance Agency

   5.0(95)· Google5.0 out of 5 from 95 reviews (Google rating)

   Insurance agency

   Closed today

   Responsive service is the clearest reason David Purvis Farm Bureau Insurance Agency earns the top spot in Birmingham, MI. Its 5.0 Google rating across 95 reviews is supported by customer accounts of returned calls and emails, helpful advice, and clear follow-up during coverage changes. Reviewers also report competitive home and auto rates, with one describing the team stepping in on a last-minute insurance update. The office at 1010 Bowers St, Suite A, opens weekdays from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. and has a wheelchair-accessible entrance and parking.

   • Responsive communication
   • Competitive rates reported
   • Wheelchair-accessible office

   “Always responsive to my calls and emails! By far the best rate for my auto and home coverage. No other company could touch it!”

   Work at David Purvis Farm Bureau Insurance Agency? Get your badge

2. 2

   Platinum Elite

   4.9(157)· Google4.9 out of 5 from 157 reviews (Google rating)

   Insurance agency

   Closed today

   Vehicle and watercraft coverage anchors Platinum Elite’s No. 2 placement, alongside a 4.9-star Google rating from 157 reviews. The agency at 400 Hamilton Row, Suite 200, in Birmingham, MI lists auto, motorcycle, RV, and watercraft insurance and advertises same-day coverage. Online appointments and onsite services offer two ways to connect during its Monday–Friday, 9 a.m.–5 p.m. hours. One reviewer says the team will “work with you on policies,” while another appreciates a price that has stayed the same.

   • Advertised same-day coverage
   • Online appointments available
   • Vehicle and watercraft insurance

   “Very good people and work with you on policies”

   Work at Platinum Elite? Get your badge

3. 3

   L.A. Insurance

   4.9(677)· Google4.9 out of 5 from 677 reviews (Google rating)

   Insurance agency

   Closed today

   Clear explanations and a smooth quoting process help earn L.A. Insurance the No. 3 spot in Birmingham, MI. Both supplied reviews describe an easy process, with customers highlighting answered questions and clearly explained information. Its 4.9 Google rating across 677 reviews adds support. The agency specializes in non-standard auto insurance and also offers motorcycle, boat, RV, and renters coverage. The office at 400 Hamilton Row, Suite 200, requires appointments and lists weekday hours of 9 a.m. to 6 p.m.

   • Non-standard auto insurance
   • Clear coverage explanations
   • Appointments required

   “Jared Chavez at L.A. Insurance helped me find the best quote for my car insurance. He was able to answer all of my questions and made the process run smoothly. Highly recommend L.A. Insurance for your insurance needs.”

   Work at L.A. Insurance? Get your badge

4. 4

   Randahl Agency, LLC

   5.0(54)· Google5.0 out of 5 from 54 reviews (Google rating)

   Insurance agency

   Closed · opens 9:00 AM

   An educator-specific focus and reviews describing helpful service earn Randahl Agency, LLC the No. 4 spot in Birmingham, MI. The women-owned agency offers Meemic car and home insurance customized for teachers and other school employees, with agents who help tailor coverage packages. Its Google listing carries a 5-star rating from 54 reviews. Customers describe quick, professional answers during policy changes and guidance through switching insurers. Online appointments and onsite services are available; appointments are required.

   • Educator-focused coverage
   • Online appointments available
   • Helpful policy guidance

   “I’m always so impressed with their helpfulness and services. As a teacher, I know I’m in good hands with Meemic Randahl Agency! We use them for auto and home insurance, and they’re easy to work with and so kind!”

   Work at Randahl Agency, LLC? Get your badge

5. 5

   Terrill Mayberry - State Farm Insurance Agent

   4.8(207)· Google4.8 out of 5 from 207 reviews (Google rating)

   Insurance agency

   Closed today

   A 4.8 Google rating across 207 reviews supports Terrill Mayberry - State Farm Insurance Agent’s fifth-place spot in Birmingham, MI. Of those reviews, 190 carry five stars, and one customer specifically credits Mayberry and his staff with finding lower-cost vehicle coverage after repeated rate increases elsewhere. The agency at 33622 Woodward Ave offers free quotes by phone or online and lists weekday hours of 9 a.m.–5 p.m. A wheelchair-accessible entrance and parking add practical access features.

   • 207 Google reviews
   • Free insurance quotes
   • Wheelchair-accessible entrance

   “Mr. Mayberry and his staff at his office are the best. They got me the cheapest vehicle insurance possible. After progressive kept increasing my rates year after year I got a call from Mr. Mayberry and he got me PLPD on my truck for $15 …”

   Work at Terrill Mayberry - State Farm Insurance Agent? Get your badge