Last updated September 18, 2026 · ranked from 1,303 Google reviews · How we rank
Attentive service distinguishes Mike Goodwin - State Farm Insurance Agent, non-standard auto coverage is a focus at L.A. Insurance, and same-day coverage sets Platinum Elite apart in Birmingham, MI. The offices put the search for insurance along East Maple Road and downtown on Hamilton Row, where L.A. Insurance and Platinum Elite share an address. At Mike Goodwin’s office, reviewers praise informative help, time spent addressing customers’ needs, and friendly service without a wait; online appointments, on-site services, and free parking add practical convenience. L.A. Insurance draws praise for clear explanations and answered questions, with motorcycle, boat, RV, and renters coverage alongside auto policies. Appointments are required there. Platinum Elite offers online appointments and on-site service, with same-day coverage available for auto, motorcycle, RV, and watercraft insurance. A reviewer also highlights its willingness to work with clients on policies—an important service detail when weighing insurance agencies in Birmingham, MI.
Top picks at a glance
1Mike Goodwin - State Farm Insurance AgentReviewers praise informative, friendly service, and the office offers online appointments, on-site services, free parking, and wheelchair-accessible entry.
2L.A. InsuranceL.A. Insurance focuses on non-standard auto insurance, with reviewers praising clear explanations, answered questions, and a smooth coverage process.
3Platinum ElitePlatinum Elite offers same-day auto, motorcycle, RV, and watercraft coverage, plus online appointments and onsite services.
5.0(184)· Google5.0 out of 5 from 184 reviews (Google rating)
Insurance agency
Closed · opens 9:00 AM
Attentive service puts Mike Goodwin - State Farm Insurance Agent at No. 1 in Birmingham, MI. Its 5-star Google rating across 184 reviews is backed by comments praising informative help, time spent making sure customers are cared for, and friendly service without a wait. The office at 966 E Maple Rd offers online appointments and on-site services, with free parking and a wheelchair-accessible entrance. Its stated focus on lasting customer relationships gives the agency a clear service-first approach.
Informative customer service
Online appointments
Free parking
“Had a great experience with Hailey!! Shes very informative and gets you the best sales”
4.9(677)· Google4.9 out of 5 from 677 reviews (Google rating)
Insurance agency
Closed · opens 9:00 AM
A focus on non-standard auto insurance, backed by a 4.9 Google rating across 677 reviews, earns L.A. Insurance the No. 2 spot in Birmingham, MI. Reviewers describe clear explanations, answered questions, and a smooth process when arranging coverage. Beyond cars, the agency offers motorcycle, boat, RV, and renters insurance, giving customers several coverage options in one office. Located at 400 Hamilton Row, Suite 200, it operates weekdays from 9 a.m. to 6 p.m. Appointments are required, and wheelchair-accessible entry and parking are available.
Non-standard auto specialty
Clear coverage explanations
Multiple coverage options
“Jared Chavez at L.A. Insurance helped me find the best quote for my car insurance. He was able to answer all of my questions and made the process run smoothly. Highly recommend L.A. Insurance for your insurance needs.”
4.9(157)· Google4.9 out of 5 from 157 reviews (Google rating)
Insurance agency
Closed · opens 9:00 AM
Same-day coverage for auto, motorcycle, RV, and watercraft insurance helps earn Platinum Elite the No. 3 spot in Birmingham, MI. Its 4.9-star Google rating across 157 reviews adds weight, while one reviewer specifically praises the agency’s willingness to work with clients on policies. Online appointments and onsite services give customers two ways to connect with the office at 400 Hamilton Row, Suite 200. Weekday hours run from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m., and the location has a wheelchair-accessible entrance and parking.
4.8(207)· Google4.8 out of 5 from 207 reviews (Google rating)
Insurance agency
Closed · opens 9:00 AM
A 4.8-star Google rating across 207 reviews anchors Terrill Mayberry - State Farm Insurance Agent’s fourth-place position. Located at 33622 Woodward Ave in Birmingham, MI, the agency offers free insurance quotes online or by phone. One reviewer credits Mayberry and his staff with finding lower-cost vehicle coverage after repeated rate increases elsewhere. The office opens Monday through Friday from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m., with a wheelchair-accessible entrance and parking providing practical access for in-person visits.
207 Google reviews
Free insurance quotes
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
“Mr. Mayberry and his staff at his office are the best. They got me the cheapest vehicle insurance possible. After progressive kept increasing my rates year after year I got a call from Mr. Mayberry and he got me PLPD on my truck for $15 …”
5.0(54)· Google5.0 out of 5 from 54 reviews (Google rating)
Insurance agency
Closed · opens 8:30 AM
Educator-focused coverage and consistently helpful service earn Randahl Agency, LLC the No. 5 spot in Birmingham, MI. The agency offers Meemic car and home insurance customized for teachers and other school employees, with agents who help tailor insurance packages. Its 5-star Google rating across 54 reviews is backed by accounts of knowledgeable staff, quick answers during policy changes, and step-by-step guidance. Located at 877 S Adams Rd, Suite 202, this women-owned agency offers online appointments and onsite services; appointments are required.
Educator-focused insurance
Helpful, knowledgeable staff
Online appointments
“Staff very helpful and knowledeable. Andi is the the best!”
5.0(8)· Google5.0 out of 5 from 8 reviews (Google rating)
Auto insurance agency
Open now · closes 12:00 AM
Clear explanations and efficient help earn Birmingham Insurance Agency the No. 6 spot in Birmingham, MI. Its Google listing carries a 5-star rating from eight reviews, with customers describing an easy auto-policy setup, courteous service and coverage options that met their needs. One reviewer says the agency helped resolve a coverage gap without penalties; others praise reasonable rates and professional assistance by phone. The office at 401 S Old Woodward Ave also has a wheelchair-accessible entrance and parking.
Clear policy explanations
Efficient phone assistance
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
“I’ve had this auto insurance for six months now and like it. Affordable pricing and great coverage for my car.”
4.4(8)· Google4.4 out of 5 from 8 reviews (Google rating)
Insurance broker
Closed · opens 8:00 AM
A broad range of services earns Hylant the No. 7 spot: the agency handles risk management, employee benefits brokerage, loss control, healthcare management and insurance for businesses and individuals. Its office at 220 Park St, Suite 102, in Birmingham, MI is part of a privately held brokerage founded in 1935. The Google listing carries a 4.4 rating from eight reviews, with reviewers praising its community involvement during the Woodward Dream Cruise. Wheelchair-accessible entry and parking add practical convenience.
Risk management services
Employee benefits brokerage
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
“Great business that gives back to the community. For the last couple years, they’ve been ever so kind as to provide the spectators of the Woodward Dream Cruise a place to rest their weary feet after a joyful day of festivities. Our gro…”
5.0(3)· Google5.0 out of 5 from 3 reviews (Google rating)
Insurance agency
Open now · closes 9:00 PM
Accounts of help after serious property losses earn Public Adjuster's Bureau Inc the No. 8 spot. One reviewer describes being treated like family after fire, smoke and water damage; another praises the decision to call after an insurer undervalued a claim. The agency at 725 S Adams Rd in Birmingham, MI holds a 5-star Google rating from three reviews. Hours extend to 9 p.m. Monday through Saturday, with Sunday hours from noon to 6 p.m. A wheelchair-accessible entrance and parking add practical convenience.
Property loss support
Evening and Sunday hours
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
“This is the most honest company I ever seen, my home was destroyed by smoke and water from a fire I lost my garage and all my personal belongings furniture and everything. This company took my case and treated me like family not only did…”
5.0(2)· Google5.0 out of 5 from 2 reviews (Google rating)
Insurance agency
Closed · opens 8:30 AM
A 5-star Google rating from two reviews puts Howes Insurance at No. 9, with practical office details rounding out its entry. The agency is located at 988 S Adams Rd, Suite 205, in Birmingham, MI, and lists wheelchair-accessible parking. Its Monday-through-Friday schedule runs from 8:30 a.m. to 4:45 p.m., providing consistent weekday hours. The positive customer ratings, identified suite location and accessible parking give this local insurance office its place on the list.
3.7(3)· Google3.7 out of 5 from 3 reviews (Google rating)
Insurance agency
Quick responses and careful handling of a complicated transaction earn Equity Title Agency its No. 10 spot. One reviewer praised its speed and responsiveness compared with other title companies; a realtor highlighted professionalism and care in a transaction involving multiple parties and title liens. Located on S Old Woodward Avenue in Birmingham, MI, the agency has a wheelchair-accessible entrance and parking. Its 3.7-star Google rating across three reviews includes a one-star account describing a delay during closing alongside two five-star reviews.
Responsive communication
Complex transaction care
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
“We've started working with Equity, they are very quick and responsive compared to other title companies we've utilized in the past!”
Map of every pick
Compare at a glance
Comparison of the best insurance agencies in Birmingham, MI
Ratings and review counts shown are Google ratings, displayed with attribution.
How we ranked this list
Each insurance agency is scored on a Bayesian-weighted rating (its rating adjusted for how many reviews it has compared with the Birmingham category average), how recently we verified its details, and how complete its listing is. Scores and ranks are stored, so the order only changes when the underlying data changes.
insurance agencies in Birmingham, MI: common questions
Which insurance agencies are included in this Birmingham, MI guide?
The guide includes L.A. Insurance, Terrill Mayberry - State Farm Insurance Agent, Mike Goodwin - State Farm Insurance Agent, Platinum Elite, David Purvis Farm Bureau Insurance Agency, Randahl Agency, LLC, Consolidated Agencies Inc, Farm Bureau Insurance - Blanchett Insurance Group, Onyxx Insurance Group, and Guardian Life Insurance Co-America.
Which listed agencies in Birmingham, MI have State Farm in their names?
Terrill Mayberry - State Farm Insurance Agent and Mike Goodwin - State Farm Insurance Agent are the two listed names. Contact each directly to confirm current offerings and availability.
Which listed agencies in Birmingham, MI have Farm Bureau in their names?
David Purvis Farm Bureau Insurance Agency and Farm Bureau Insurance - Blanchett Insurance Group both have Farm Bureau in their names. The provided information does not describe their policies or services.
Which insurance agency in Birmingham, MI offers the lowest prices?
No pricing information was provided, so this guide cannot identify the least expensive agency. Request quotes for the same insurance needs and compare the stated coverage and costs.
How should I choose among these insurance agencies in Birmingham, MI?
Start by asking whether each agency offers the insurance you need. Then ask about coverage terms, costs, and whom you would contact with questions. The supplied names alone do not support a recommendation of one agency over another.
1
